Idk if this has been said before, if so sorry for repeating it. I was just thinking about MF, and just by looking at him, i had a little theory about who/what he is.

 

It kinda makes sense that he would be Master Xehanort's nobody. His weapons are similar to the light saber looking things used by Xemnas, who was the nobody of Terranort. And if you think about it, Master Xehanort did the same thing Sora did with his keyblade, Used the keyblade to unlock his own heart, thus creating Roxas. so wouldn't it make sense for a nobody to be created from MX since it was the exact same process sora did to create roxas? Hes even wearing organization robes, so even his appearance screams nobody.

 

Again, sorry if someone already came up with this, just an idea that came to be sitting bored in school.

I like to think i blew lid off the whole affair when hatok dubbed me the expert on the subject of MF! Im always well versed on the ins, outs and intricasies of his gender

yes to the fact that possible, do I think that is true, no

 

I honestly think MF is a new charcter altogether, I think his power are to manipulated time, if you ask me he will be a villain in KH3d, khBBSV2 or KH3

 

just my thoughts

both plausible theories, only time will tell.

Just because MF is wearing a Organization robe doesn't mean he's a nobody. So I guess Mickey, Ansem, Xehanort and Riku are nobodies as well? lol The difference between Sora and Xehanort is that Sora became a heartless, which created the nobody, and Xehanort transferred his heart into Terra.

Master Xehanort didn't turn into a Heartless like Sora and thus doesn't have a Nobody. He could be an old character or a completely new one but i think he's a new character. Perhaps even an old aquaintance of MX.

Master Xehanort didn't turn into a Heartless like Sora and thus doesn't have a Nobody. He could be an old character or a completely new one but i think he's a new character. Perhaps even an old aquaintance of MX.

 

Thanks for agreeing with me.

No. To create a Nobody, a Heartless must be created. A Heartless is created when someone loses thier heart to darkness. Then, if the person has a strong enough heart, the body and soul turn into a Nobody.

 

However, MX didn't lose his heart to darkness, he just put it into Terra. With his heart in Terra, it couldn't turn into a Heartless. Therefore, it's impossible for him to have a Nobody.

 

As someone else stated, the difference between MX releasing his heart and Sora releasing his heart is MX's heart was put into Terra, while Sora's went into darkness and became the Shadow Heartless we played as for a little bit.

See, this is where I disagree with you.

 

Do I think it is fact? No.

 

Do I think it is Plausible? Yes.

 

What is A heartless but a heart without its original body? (Excluding the Emblem Heartless.) It is completely plausible for a Nobody to be created from MX's Transfer. Even if it is just for 50 milliseconds, his heart had no body in which to live, thus making him a heartless.

 

Wasn't Sora a Heartless (in a way) until he joined with Roxas at the beginning of KH2?

He may have gotten a temporary vessel do to Kairi's light, but the only difference between Sora as a shadow and Sora after Kairi hugged him is what made up his new body. Darkness before, light afterwards.

 

(Sorry this may be stated as a fact, but I was just stating my view point.)

See, this is where I disagree with you.

 

Do I think it is fact? No.

 

Do I think it is Plausible? Yes.

 

What is A heartless but a heart without its original body? (Excluding the Emblem Heartless.) It is completely plausible for a Nobody to be created from MX's Transfer. Even if it is just for 50 milliseconds, his heart had no body in which to live, thus making him a heartless.

 

Wasn't Sora a Heartless (in a way) until he joined with Roxas at the beginning of KH2?

He may have gotten a temporary vessel do to Kairi's light, but the only difference between Sora as a shadow and Sora after Kairi hugged him is what made up his new body. Darkness before, light afterwards.

 

(Sorry this may be stated as a fact, but I was just stating my view point.)

 

Actually a Heartless is created by a heart getting swallowed by darkness. The heart itself becomes the Heartless. So even though his heart was out of his body for a brief period of time, no Heartless was created.

 

It's kinda ironic really. The Heartless is actually the heart, and the Nobody is actually the body and soul.

 

As for Sora being a Heartless until the begining of KH2, that's actually true. Really, what we play as from when he turns into a Heartless, throughout CoM, to the begining of KH2, is his Heartless. It's just Kairi created a shell-like body to hold his heart. But techinically he is still a Heartless, just one that has a human form.

i dont know if this has anything to do with this, but wasnt Xehanort in a Organization XIII hoodie at the beggining of Birth By Sleep? When he was leaving Ventus on Destiny Island?

i dont know if this has anything to do with this, but wasnt Xehanort in a Organization XIII hoodie at the beggining of Birth By Sleep? When he was leaving Ventus on Destiny Island?

 

Yes. The coat is his design. Xemnas, who is Terranort (Terra with MX's heart posessing him) Nobody used the design of the coat for the Organization members.

Actually a Heartless is created by a heart getting swallowed by darkness. The heart itself becomes the Heartless. So even though his heart was out of his body for a brief period of time, no Heartless was created.

 

It's kinda ironic really. The Heartless is actually the heart, and the Nobody is actually the body and soul.

 

As for Sora being a Heartless until the begining of KH2, that's actually true. Really, what we play as from when he turns into a Heartless, throughout CoM, to the begining of KH2, is his Heartless. It's just Kairi created a shell-like body to hold his heart. But techinically he is still a Heartless, just one that has a human form.

 

Exactly, the heartless that we kill are just hearts with dark embodiments. Sora was a heartless with an embodiment of light.

 

Namora could argue that Xehanort turned into a heartless during the brief seconds before he was transferred into Terra.

 

All I am saying is that it is plausible. No one should doubt the possibilities.

THERE WERENT HEARTLESS UNTIL KH1. RAAAAAAAWR

THERE WERENT HEARTLESS UNTIL KH1. RAAAAAAAWR

 

Actually, Heartless have always existed. The Emblem Heartless didn't exist until after BBS, but the Pureblood Heartless have always existed. Neoshadows attacked Ven and MX's command. And in BBSFM, during the secret episode, Aqua fights several Heartless.

I love your theory, thank you for posting this. Seriously. But then again, Master Xehanort didn't become a heartless. He just made his heart take over Terra's.

 

Also, at people who say that from KHI to the part of II when Roxas becomes one with Sora, Sora is a heartless, and Antiform actually is proof.