Hi there!!! I've been a little abscent these days because of school and because my laptop got all mixed up... 8`(

Anyway I've been wondering why people keeps saying that Ven's Heart left Sora's body and went to Roxas??? I mean I don't really think that Roxas had Ven's Heart. It's like at the beginning of BBS when Sora helps Ven to save his fractured heart, Vanitas was born from Ven with Sora's face BECAUSE of that union but it didn't have Sora's Heart. It seems possible that Roxas had Ven's Heart but still there's something weird that doesn't feel quite right. In the secret ending in BBSFM we see that Ven flashes and then he's gone. I've been thinking that maybe when roxas was created Ven's Heart left to find it's own body and now is missing. That's why Mickey says in Blank Points that they're close to find Ven's Heart.

 

What do you guys think about this??

Ven's heart did actually leave Sora's body since Sora stabbed himself with the keyblade of hearts. When that happened, Ven's heart needed to find another vessel to have, so it chose Roxas's body siince he was Sora's nobody. That's why he looks exactly like Ven and also why he is able to feel emotions.

What KH125 said.

Ven's heart did actually leave Sora's body since Sora stabbed himself with the keyblade of hearts. When that happened, Ven's heart needed to find another vessel to have, so it chose Roxas's body siince he was Sora's nobody. That's why he looks exactly like Ven and also why he is able to feel emotions.

 

wait i thought i didnt leave but it just stayed in the body when roxas got it

wait i thought i didnt leave but it just stayed in the body when roxas got it

No, it transferred to Roxas's body the moment Roxas was born. If Ven's heart stayed in Sora's body then Roxas would've looked like Sora.

i am going to youtube and i am going to count how many hearts come out of sore went he stabbed himself.them i said if yes or no

nevermind only 7 hearts came out they made a mistake on that one but yeah ventus heart left soras body

No, it transferred to Roxas's body the moment Roxas was born. If Ven's heart stayed in Sora's body then Roxas would've looked like Sora.

 

Actually, it's the other way around. Sora released his and Kairi's hearts. Ven's heart stayed in Sora's body, which turned into Roxas. Since the body had Ven's heart, it changed to look like Ven. If Ven's heart had left Sora's body, Roxas would look like Sora, and Ven's heart would return to Ven's body.

 

When a Nobody is created, the Sombody's body and soul turn into the Nobody. After Roxas was created, Sora was given a body-like shell by Kairi with her PoH powers, however he's still technically a Heartless, just with a shell. Kinda like Ansem SoD in Riku's body. At the begining of KH2, after the 6th day, Roxas combines with Sora, giving him his body back.

 

No, it transferred to Roxas's body the moment Roxas was born. If Ven's heart stayed in Sora's body then Roxas would've looked like Sora.

 

Actually, it's the other way around. Sora released his and Kairi's hearts. Ven's heart stayed in Sora's body, which turned into Roxas. Since the body had Ven's heart, it changed to look like Ven. If Ven's heart had left Sora's body, Roxas would look like Sora, and Ven's heart would return to Ven's body.

 

When a Nobody is created, the Sombody's body and soul turn into the Nobody. After Roxas was created, Sora was given a body-like shell by Kairi with her PoH powers, however he's still technically a Heartless, just with a shell. Kinda like Ansem SoD in Riku's body. At the begining of KH2, after the 6th day, Roxas combines with Sora, giving him his body back.

 

This is how I understand it.

When he stabbed himself with the Hearts of the people keyblade it released all hearts that were in Sora's heart.In other words:

Kairi's heart returned to Kairi

Ventus's heart went to Roxas body

Sora's heart somehow stayed in his own body

The reason Roxas look like Ventus is Sora had Ventus's heart when Roxas was created his body took shape of Ventus's body.And maybe Ventus's heart went to Roxas's body is Ventus' body=Roxas's body

I thought Roxas is a nobody, and I thought nobodys can't feel emotions.

But its also said that roxas and namine are special nobodies. Roxas got created like a nobody (heart leaves somebody and become heartless, body [and soul] turns into nobody) but because of ven he isnt like the others.

Just look at the the ending at days with xion, there u can see that he has feelings.

 

I also believe that vens heart left soras body when he stabbed himself.

The argument that if vens heart would have left he would have gone back to vens body isnt plausible in my opinion.

So why did ven not just go back to his body in the first place?

Because his heart was surrounded by darkness, he didnt know where his body or anthing is. It was soras voice that cut through the darkness and made ven fnd him.

So why did yen sid tell aqua that she has to believe in ven in order that he can turn back if his heart can turn back on his own once its released? (rethorical question).

------------------ delted double post--------------------------------

But its also said that roxas and namine are special nobodies. Roxas got created like a nobody (heart leaves somebody and become heartless, body [and soul] turns into nobody) but because of ven he isnt like the others.

Just look at the the ending at days with xion, there u can see that he has feelings.

 

I also believe that vens heart left soras body when he stabbed himself.

The argument that if vens heart would have left he would have gone back to vens body isnt plausible in my opinion.

So why did ven not just go back to his body in the first place?

Because his heart was surrounded by darkness, he didnt know where his body or anthing is. It was soras voice that cut through the darkness and made ven fnd him.

So why did yen sid tell aqua that she has to believe in ven in order that he can turn back if his heart can turn back on his own once its released? (rethorical question).

 

Like Azure Flame said, Ven's heart didn't leave Sora's body. Sora's heart left.

 

I agree with your ideas on Ven not returning to his own body, but he never left Sora's. In order to have a nobody, you need a body. Roxas is Sora's nobody. Ven's heart was with Roxas.

Well in the end it doesnt matter so much anyways (at least for me) whether vens heart stayed inside soras body or if he chose to go back into soras body.

I havent found any evidence that would proove which happend anyways.

 

But for those who like unlikely theories how about that:

Like said before if the heart leaves the body and doesnt turn into a heartless it seems to be covered in darkness and it needs a voice/light which cut through the darkness so that it can find a new vessel.

So if vens heart left soras body with the hearts of soras and kairis how did it find back to soras body (roxas)?

Was there anyone left thinking and searching of him?

The first person which roxas met was xemnas (if i recall correctly).

And oh wait didnt have xemnas some of terras memories and wanted to find his old friend ven?

So maybe he followed this time (terras) xemnas voice and found so soras body back.

 

Yeah i know its pretty unlikely but well i kinda like the theory^^.

Well in the end it doesnt matter so much anyways (at least for me) whether vens heart stayed inside soras body or if he chose to go back into soras body.

I havent found any evidence that would proove which happend anyways.

 

But for those who like unlikely theories how about that:

Like said before if the heart leaves the body and doesnt turn into a heartless it seems to be covered in darkness and it needs a voice/light which cut through the darkness so that it can find a new vessel.

So if vens heart left soras body with the hearts of soras and kairis how did it find back to soras body (roxas)?

Was there anyone left thinking and searching of him?

The first person which roxas met was xemnas (if i recall correctly).

And oh wait didnt have xemnas some of terras memories and wanted to find his old friend ven?

So maybe he followed this time (terras) xemnas voice and found so soras body back.

 

Yeah i know its pretty unlikely but well i kinda like the theory^^.

 

Hmm. Like you said, unlikely but it does have some logic to it.