This threads going to compare the only two all-star stories dc ever made.All star Batman and Robin and All-Star Superman.

 

Writing:

All Star Batman and Robin

I don’t need to say any more this proved Frank Miller can’t write comics anymore.

 

All-Star Superman

Grant Morrsion takes all his wonderfully crazy ideas and reinvents superman while paying tribute to golden age of comics.He makes Superman a god but not unstoppable while making Superman something people should look up to and want to be like.One of best Superhero’s stories in the history of comics.

 

Winner: Anything that’s not Modern Miller aka Brilliant Mind of Grant Morrsion and Superman

 

 

 

Art:

Frank Quitely who did All-star Superman and Jim Lee who did All-Star Batman and Robin.Both did great jobs with there story but chemistry between Quitely and Morrison is the best since Loeb and Sale and it can’t be beat and for chemistry for Jim Lee see image of writing and you will see that Lee was at too much of a disadvantage.

Winner: All-Star Superman but Lee was born to drawn Batman

 

Most Famous Moment

 

All-Star Batman and Robin

 

All-Star Superman

 

One shows how great of character he is and why he is one of greatest superhero’s of all-time and the other well Crazy Steve should not be taking abducting kids.

Winner: Do i even need to say who the winner is

 

 

Accomplishments

(I’m stealing this one from Linkara but he so right about it and also check out his All-Star Batman and Robin reviews they are funny. http://atopfourthwal...in-3-and-4.html

 

 

Superman:

 

-saving the first manned mission to the sun.

-brewing the Super–Elixir.

-answering the Unanswerable Question.

-chaining the Chronovore.

-saving Earth from Bizarro–Home.

-returning from the Underverse.

-creating Life.

-liberating Kandor/cures cancer.

-defeating Solaris.

-conquering Death.

-builds an artificial Heart for the Sun.

-leaves the recipe/formula to make Superman 2.

-Caring about everyone

-Saving real people lives

 

 

(Look he made Bruce Wayne creeper.Nice!)

Batman

-Ended the All-Star line of comics

-Batman Planed to kill Robin’s parents

-No planing of script

-Being an unfinished trash bag

-Making Batman a joke again while in not being funny

-Almost ruining Batman:Year One

-People somehow liked this? (They should go to Arkham Asylum)

Winner: All-Star Superman

 

In everything single way All-Star Superman is better than Frank Miller twisted

piece of garbage known as Batman and Robin

(Oh hell why not show more Batman and Robin)

 

 

batman is still better case closed

batman is still better case closed

 

cause kidnapping kids is better than cursing cancer?

tl;dr

 

Also you know who reads way too much Manga if he tries to read these comics from right to left and thinks that it doesn't make f*cking sense.

 

@topic: Dunno if you compare single comics or the awesomeness of Batman and Superman but if it's the latter option I just say my opinion that I prefer Batman over Superman. Always have always will.

cause kidnapping kids is better than cursing cancer?

 

Kidnapping is always a good thing http://kh13.com/forum/public/style_emoticons/default/happy.png

tl;dr

 

Also you know who reads way too much Manga if he tries to read these comics from right to left and thinks that it doesn't make f*cking sense.

 

@topic: Dunno if you compare single comics or the awesomeness of Batman and Superman but if it's the latter option I just say my opinion that I prefer Batman over Superman. Always have always will.

 

i never said though.I proving that superman can be better than batman and nothing shows that better than all-star line and in all-star line Superman is way better.

Kidnapping is always a good thing http://kh13.com/forum/public/style_emoticons/default/happy.png

 

And eating rats makes for healthy diet? and you agree with that mid aged man should be able to kidnap a 12 year old who parents recently died to make him into superhero even maybe going to limits of killing parents yourself even when kid does not agree to it?

i never said though.I proving that superman can be better than batman and nothing shows that better than all-star line and in all-star line Superman is way better.

 

I am not someone who you call a specialist when it comes to comics so excuse me if I seem amateurish while asking "what is an all-star line?".

Also I think this is only a matter of opinion in the topic of "Which Superhero is the best". I mean you can argue about individual comics since better writing or drawings are facts but when it comes to the image of the Superhero itself it's all about opinion and personal taste and no facts at all.

I like the darker story behind Batman. I like that he is a mere human who worked very hard for his technological advantages his fighting skill and so on. I like the reason why he wants to be a superhero. As a simple man who fights against injustice because of the things that were done to him and his parents it feels easier to sympathize with him and see it all in his perspective.

I am not someone who you call a specialist when it comes to comics so excuse me if I seem amateurish while asking "what is an all-star line?".

Also I think this is only a matter of opinion in the topic of "Which Superhero is the best". I mean you can argue about individual comics since better writing or drawings are facts but when it comes to the image of the Superhero itself it's all about opinion and personal taste and no facts at all.

I like the darker story behind Batman. I like that he is a mere human who worked very hard for his technological advantages his fighting skill and so on. I like the reason why he wants to be a superhero. As a simple man who fights against injustice because of the things that were done to him and his parents it feels easier to sympathize with him and see it all in his perspective.

 

I never said i liked any superhero more but when it comes to all-star line Batman is creepy and Superman is ultimate hero.

 

The All-star line was supposed to relaunch well known dc comic book characters where you wouldn't have to know any of there history they started off with two, one was All-Star Batman and Robin and the Other was All-Star Superman.After backlash of All-star batman and robin they cancelled the line.All-Star Superman is known as one of greatest comics ever made.It's not really up for debate who's better All-star superman or Batman.

I never said i liked any superhero more but when it comes to all-star line Batman is creepy and Superman is ultimate hero.

 

The All-star line was supposed to relaunch well known dc comic book characters where you wouldn't have to know any of there history they started off with two, one was All-Star Batman and Robin and the Other was All-Star Superman.After backlash of All-star batman and robin they cancelled the line.All-Star Superman is known as one of greatest comics ever made.It's not really up for debate who's better All-star superman or Batman.

 

Oh well isn't it then the fault of the author who surprise-raped Batman and all for what he stands for?

Oh well isn't it then the fault of the author who surprise-raped Batman and all for what he stands for?

 

Well he is the guy who created modern image of Batman with such books as Batman:year one and The Dark Knight Returns which movies and tv shows use without them the 60's image of Batman would still stand.So he really raped himself.

Well he is the guy who created modern image of Batman with such books as Batman:year one and The Dark Knight Returns which movies and tv shows use without them the 60's image of Batman would still stand.So he really raped himself.

 

Well all I know from Batman are the 90's movies, the cartoons in the 90's, the Arkham Asylum graphic novel, Nolan's newest Batman trilogy and the old Adam West series. Except for the last one and a few of the first one all of them were great.

I Think Superman is Public Wise, The All Star of D.C Comics, Considering the Dark Nature of Batman's Stories but Personally, I think Batman is way more Better then Superman is.

Well all I know from Batman are the 90's movies, the cartoons in the 90's, the Arkham Asylum graphic novel, Nolan's newest Batman trilogy and the old Adam West series. Except for the last one and a few of the first one all of them were great.

 

All of those took something for Frank miller work.He made James Gordon an important character and other things.All of those stuff are great and i like 60's show for it's goofiness.

 

 

I Think Superman is Public Wise, The All Star of D.C Comics, Considering the Dark Nature of Batman's Stories but Personally i think Batman is way more Better then Superman is.

 

I never said he wasn't all i said was All-Star series wise Superman had superior series than Batman.Batman is the poster boy of DC at the moment and has best series at DC thanks to Scott Snyder.Most people now days Hate Superman and Love Batman.I love both and All-star superman proves Superman shouldn't get this hate.

 

Please I want this thread not to turn into a comic history lesson and i want to go back to a comedy.Anyone?Please Ventus,KairiSora06,MarluXia777,Cella.Please Help!

ALL-STAR SUPERMAN WAS WONDERRRRFFFUUUULLLL. I mean I liked it a lot but I haven't read the other one yet to make a fair judgement between the two series but I really did grow a greater love for Superman after I read that. But I love both of them but I've never thought either deserved hate like how Superman typically gets nowadays. and lol I sort of see the puns

ALL-STAR SUPERMAN WAS WONDERRRRFFFUUUULLLL. I mean I liked it a lot but I haven't read the other one yet to make a fair judgement between the two series but I really did grow a greater love for Superman after I read that. But I love both of them but I've never thought either deserved hate like how Superman typically gets nowadays. and lol I sort of see the puns

 

All-Star Superman was one of my all-time comics and i agree it makes you love Superman.Don't read All-star Batman and robin read Batman:The long Hallowen or Year One instead. People don't give Sup's the fair chance hopefully the Man of Steel film can change that.Thank You!!! So much for making this thread not feel like a totally failure you have that affect on alot of my threads if you were here i would properly go crazy and get myself banned and i love you for that.

 

I wonder how many of you actually looked though what i said because on opening line that said "This threads going to compare the only two all-star stories dc ever made.All star Batman and Robin and All-Star Superman".Am guessing most you look at title and put something about Batman being better without looking over the thread.The pun which may have been confusing and done very good was pun at All-Star line by saying that Superman is real All-star saying that his is better.In no way am i saying Superman is better than Batman but pointing out failure in All-Star Batman and Robin and the awesome of All-Star Superman.Now my

Adamantium Rage is over.Thank You for your time call is important to us.

 

(But can he save this thread?)