1. why did the killer think putting people in the tv would save them? (please give me a complete answer. ive been wondering this for a long time)

 

2. does dojima ever believe narukami's story about the tv?

 

3. does narukami ever come back to inaba?

 

4. why wasent a shadow created when nanako entered the tv world?

 

5. was the killer working together with his shadow?

3, yes in persona 4 :arena.

1. Uhhh which "killer" are you referring to?

 

2. Yea towards the end when Nanako was kidnapped

 

3.Yes in P4A oh yea and in the true ending of P4Golden (but nothing really happens besides some crazy character developments)

 

4.This...

Nanako is the only person that didn't manifest a shadow. This is likely due to the fact that, because of her young age, she does not have enough repressed thoughts and emotions to form a proper Shadow.

• Carl Jung, whose theories on personas, shadows, and the tarot have been used as the basis of thePersona series, believed that an individual forms a persona (and thus, a shadow) at the age where they first enter into the world—an age that Nanako had likely not reached at the time of her kidnapping. Her lack of a Shadow may reference this theory.
• Another possibility is that Nanako had already accepted her Shadow; she admitted that when her mother died, she felt lonely at the start, but when she saw that she had so many people caring about her, she overcame her weakness (and thus, overcame her Shadow).

5.Maybe i don't think its ever explained in the Game or Anime but i would say he was at least aware of it especially the way he acts in the anime

 

Edited January 18, 201312 yr by Allpro11414

1. Uhhh which "killer" are you referring to?

 

2. Yea towards the end when Nanako was kidnapped

 

3.Yes in P4A oh yea and in the true ending of P4Golden (but nothing really happens besides some crazy character developments)

 

4.This...

Nanako is the only person that didn't manifest a shadow. This is likely due to the fact that, because of her young age, she does not have enough repressed thoughts and emotions to form a proper Shadow.

• Carl Jung, whose theories on personas, shadows, and the tarot have been used as the basis of thePersona series, believed that an individual forms a persona (and thus, a shadow) at the age where they first enter into the world—an age that Nanako had likely not reached at the time of her kidnapping. Her lack of a Shadow may reference this theory.
• Another possibility is that Nanako had already accepted her Shadow; she admitted that when her mother died, she felt lonely at the start, but when she saw that she had so many people caring about her, she overcame her weakness (and thus, overcame her Shadow).

5.Maybe i don't think its ever explained in the Game or Anime but i would say he was at least aware of it especially the way he acts in the anime

 

i'm talking about namatame

1. He thought that because Yukiko (who was the first person he actually kidnapped) came from the TV world alive. Kanji, Rise, and Naoto coming out alive just put fuel to the fire.

 

2. The game never really directly addresses that . He knows Narukami did something right in order to save Nanako when Dojima couldn't do jack, so by the end of the game Dojima just trusts that he knows what he's doing.

 

3. Yes, he goes back at the start of Persona 4:Arena and in the special Epilogue of Golden sometime later.

 

4. Namatame's Messiah Complex was more attractive to the shadows than her. Areas of the TV world are shaped by the feelings of those who wander into it. Shadows are created from the desires and denial of the people who enter the areas (I.E., Saki Konishi creating the shopping district but Yosuke creating the shadow). Namatame had a several powerful internal neuroses to fuel their appearance. Nanako had grief, which was strong enough to drown out Namatame in making the world, but Nanako didn't have outstanding internalized beliefs stemming from it. The level of consciousness may also be a factor (Nanako was half-dead by the time they found her.)

 

5. In both cases, no. The shadows attached (or possessed, depending on how you look at it) themselves to them once they completely lost their marbles.

Edited January 18, 201312 yr by Spectrum of Life

1. He thought that because Yukiko (who was the first person he actually kidnapped) came from the TV world alive. Kanji, Rise, and Naoto coming out alive just put fuel to the fire.

 

2. The game never really directly addresses that . He knows Narukami did something right in order to save Nanako when Dojima couldn't do jack, so by the end of the game Dojima just trusts that he knows what he's doing.

 

3. Yes, he goes back at the start of Persona 4:Arena and in the special Epilogue of Golden sometime later.

 

4. Namatame's Messiah Complex was more attractive to the shadows than her. Areas of the TV world are shaped by the feelings of those who wander into it. Shadows are created from the desires and denial of the people who enter the areas (I.E., Saki Konishi creating the shopping district but Yosuke creating the shadow). Namatame had a several powerful internal neuroses to fuel their appearance. Nanako had grief, which was strong enough to drown out Namatame in making the world, but Nanako didn't have outstanding internalized beliefs stemming from it. The level of consciousness may also be a factor (Nanako was half-dead by the time they found her.)

 

5. In both cases, no. The shadows attached (or possessed, depending on how you look at it) themselves to them once they completely lost their marbles.

if you can answer all the questions, i have more for you:

 

did the golden special epilogue take place after or before arena?

 

does arena also have a similar story to the first game?

 

who is the new villain in arena?

 

does namatame actually become mayor?

 

how can i see what happened during winter in the game. for me it just skipped the whole winter when i got to it and i heard that theres a way to see what happened in it.

 

do you also have the freedom you have in the first p4 game in arena?

 

are they making more p4 games?

After. Arena takes place in May 2012, P4G's epilogue takes place in 2013.

 

Yes and no. The plot for most of the Investigation Team is basically rescuing another person (Labrys, though they were initially just investigating why the Midnight Channel turns back on and learn about her later) from the TV world and discovering whoever is behind it. The portions of the game surrounding Naoto, Labrys and the P3 cast are significantly different. Naoto's and the Ex-S.E.E.S. members revolve around finding what was stolen during a plane hijacking as well as who was behind it), and Elizabeth's is about understanding what it'll take to save the protagonist of Persona 3, culminating in receiving her own Fool Arcana card.

 

The antagonists (There's two) of Arena are a hacker that wants to use Labrys as the ultimate weapon and an unidentified supernatural entity using him a puppet.. Theories are floating around that it's Nyarlathotep (The Villain of Persona 2)

 

Arena is mostly linear. You can choose to an extent what characters you play as first, but the storylines themselves have only one path, save for a few dialogue options that determine whether or not you complete the route or get a joke ending.

 

And in all likelihood there's going to be at least 1 more sequel, as Arena ends with the Investigation Team planning to go to Tatsumi Port Island.

After. Arena takes place in May 2012, P4G's epilogue takes place in 2013.

 

Yes and no. The plot for most of the Investigation Team is basically rescuing another person (Labrys, though they were initially just investigating why the Midnight Channel turns back on and learn about her later) from the TV world and discovering whoever is behind it. The portions of the game surrounding Naoto, Labrys and the P3 cast are significantly different. Naoto's and the Ex-S.E.E.S. members revolve around finding what was stolen during a plane hijacking as well as who was behind it), and Elizabeth's is about understanding what it'll take to save the protagonist of Persona 3, culminating in receiving her own Fool Arcana card.

 

The antagonists (There's two) of Arena are a hacker that wants to use Labrys as the ultimate weapon and an unidentified supernatural entity using him a puppet.. Theories are floating around that it's Nyarlathotep (The Villain of Persona 2)

 

Arena is mostly linear. You can choose to an extent what characters you play as first, but the storylines themselves have only one path, save for a few dialogue options that determine whether or not you complete the route or get a joke ending.

 

And in all likelihood there's going to be at least 1 more sequel, as Arena ends with the Investigation Team planning to go to Tatsumi Port Island.

the only persona game i've played is p4g. will i get cofused if i play arena?

the only persona game i've played is p4g. will i get confused if i play arena?

 

Not really. They recap most of the previous games' story. The only things that I can imagine being confusing are what the company that made the androids did in the past and what leads up to the start of Elizabeth's story.

http://kh13.com/forum/topic/46944-persona-4/