okay we all know that from everyone who loses their heart gets a heartless and a nobody so we know that sora lost his heart and that created roxas where and who is soras heartless?

he doesnt have one unless you can say van is his heartless

That would be tight! I don't know if that would work though, because Van was way before Sora even lost his heart.

You play as sora's shadow in Kh1 at hallow bastion, Kairi notices its sora hugs him and he turns back to human form but he was still a heartless up until he reunited with roxas in Kh2[/color][/size]

Ok first of all not everyone who loses their heart has a nobody only the people who have strong hearts have nobodies. And second Sora was a shadow for a small amount of time in Hollow Bastion until he met with Kairi's heart and then he got his original form back (Thats also why Roxas couldn't remember anything about Sora).

okay we all know that from everyone who loses their heart gets a heartless and a nobody so we know that sora lost his heart and that created roxas where and who is soras heartless?

 

Not everyone who loses their heart to the darkness create a Nobody. Only those with strong hearts will create them.

 

Sora's Heartless was the little Shadow you were playing as in Hollow Bastion after he stabbed himself. Having only little darkness in his heart, he produced a weak Heartless.

<-------- Sora's Heartless

 

Sora's heartless was that tiny Shadow you controlled for about... five minutes in KH1 until Kairi protected it through hug, which changed Sora back to his original human self.

 

 

 

Honestly, this discussion can't really go any further, so I'll lock it for now.

Feel free to PM if you have any questions or feel that the discussion can continue...

._. Although people would just start to repeat one another...