I know the mangas are mostly non canon but isn't the histoira supposed to have everything in there official? this is about the Hyrule Historia if u didn't know

It might be. In Skyward sword the Goron that is in the desert says this, "I could not believe my eyes when I saw a human who lives on the legendary Isle of the Goddess. It wore clothes just like the ones written about in the ancient manuscripts and it looked just like you, bud." This is basically saying that it's possible that the Goron saw a person with the same clothes that SS Link has on meaning that there could of been another Link before SSLink . 

It might be. In Skyward sword the Goron that is in the desert says this, "I could not believe my eyes when I saw a human who lives on the legendary Isle of the Goddess. It wore clothes just like the ones written about in the ancient manuscripts and it looked just like you, bud." This is basically saying that it's possible that the Goron saw a person with the same clothes that SS Link has on meaning that there could of been another Link before SSLink . 

so that would mean the Link before SS Link is still alive during SS but I thought he died at the end.or hes a god now

so that would mean the Link before SS Link is still alive during SS but I thought he died at the end.or hes a god now

The Link the existed before SS Link died and as a result of him dieing SSLink is the reincarnation of him.

The Link the existed before SS Link died and as a result of him dieing SSLink is the reincarnation of him.

yeah I get that.what I ment was it almost sounds like that Goron saw the other Link running around. that what I got out of it anyway

yeah I get that.what I ment was it almost sounds like that Goron saw the other Link running around. that what I got out of it anyway

yeah that's what it seems like. Now I think that it might actually be canon and the cool thing is that this might be the only zelda manga that is canon. 

Edited May 20, 201411 yr by Zeldablade7

yeah that's what it seems like. Now I think that it might actually be canon and the cool thing is that this might be the only zelda manga that is canon. 

I guess we'll see during Zeldas 50th year. and we get the Hyrule Historia vol.2 

I guess we'll see during Zeldas 50th year. and we get the Hyrule Historia vol.2 

cool.They might need to do that because they basically need to update the timeline because future zelda games are getting released. 

I would assume it's canon mainly due to the fact that it's in the Hyrule Historia.  Though the Link in the manga is long dead, however, his spirit may still reside in the Surface.

I assume it is canon, since it is at the end of HH, and it doesn't exactly contradicts what is in the game, actually it compliments it quite nicely, for various reasons:

 

1. Faron mentions that Link doesn't look at all like the Goddess's chosen Hero, something that doesn't make sense if SS Link would had been the first Link.

 

2. Zelda mentioned in the Wing Ceremony, that in the ancient past, the Goddess Hylia gave a sailcloth to her chosen hero. This is the chosen hero she spoke of, though Hylia is not seen giving him a sailcloth.

 

3. When Link finishes forging the Master Sword, Fi says the sword has "reveal" its true form, so the MS had looked that way before being the GS and been reforged by Link, afterall, they do know how to forge it already.

 

It also works with what past games say, without contradicting SS, about the Master Sword being forged by ancient sages, which by the manga is true, since the Master Sword of the Gods was destroyed, and reforged into the Mortal Master Sword, by various blacksmiths along that Link.

 

Though sure, it kinda contradicts what Demise says about the humans running away in fear at the mere sight of him, but he could had simply confused the other Link with SS Link, it is not like they are that different, The only differences is that Manga Link seemed to be more muscular than what SS Link was, but it is not like that would be anything noticeable for Demise.

Edited May 21, 201411 yr by tlozbj