Sir Adamus

Don't blame me for the name. I know some weird people, and the name stuck.

so...neither of them? RAGAWHIMADOODOODAAAAHHHH RAGAWHIMADADOODADAAAAHHH! UNLEASH YOUR RAGASPARK UNTO MY OPPONENT!

It's going fine..... ..... ....how are you?

Hooray! May I enquire as to why?

TURN OFF CAPS LOCK, IT'S VERY DISTRACTING. None of us know when 3D happens, though we predict that it's probably after Coded. Bare in mind that these images have been taken from something that is far from the final product. The models of Sora and Riku may just be placeholders for the KH2 models. soz about the caps, so they are using them as a mdel then putting the kh2 characters on there to replace the modles Well, that's what we think they are doing.

It's not that I'm annoying, as it is, but people get annoyed by me. Entirely dependant on whether or not you like being proved wrong. Is that so? gotta admit, I don't like being proved wrong> ... Joke! lol. Well, I seem to have the habit of annoying people at the wrong time;3 or least, I'm good at annoying meh mother:p A claim to fame many people have, to be sure.

TURN OFF CAPS LOCK, IT'S VERY DISTRACTING. None of us know when 3D happens, though we predict that it's probably after Coded. Bare in mind that these images have been taken from something that is far from the final product. The models of Sora and Riku may just be placeholders for the KH2 models.

It's not that I'm annoying, as it is, but people get annoyed by me. Entirely dependant on whether or not you like being proved wrong.

ALL HAIL NOMURA!!!! *raises drink in toast* Hail Nomura.

Good enough for me! Thankies.

With all the Xehanort Reports. If you don't have those and have already gone and beaten the person's final boss, you'll have to go get them, then beat the final boss again, and if you originally had trouble with that boss, well best of luck, again. You don't actually, all you have to do is collect them (if you've already beaten the final bosses). I was worried about that, so I collected them, saved, and then I got a message saying I'd unlocked the final episode, create a save and blah blah blah.

So, yeah, intro thread. Hi, the name is Sir Adamus, but you guys can call me Adam. Feel free to hate me, I'll probably be annoying a lot of you.

Eh? When was that implied? Seriously, when?

No, I'm not. I just think it's stupid to blindly follow a theory when very little evidence is provided to support it. Meanwhile, I've gotten some pretty solid evidence to the contrary. Xion acknowledged that SHE was a fake, but not that her Keyblade was. The mere fact that she had a heart at all means she has the potential to use a keyblade (see Data Sora, a data replica of our Keyblade hero who ends up in the possession of a very real Keyblade). And so what if she's absorbing energy from Roxas? How does that even counter my previous argument? Even though she was absorbing energy from him, that wouldn't matter if her Keyblade was fake, as you all so claim, because she still wouldn't have the power to release the hearts from the Heartless. And opinions are not fact, that's why they're opinions, duh. Bottom line, aside from like two very tenuous sources (ie, a cutscene and a throwaway line in the Ultimania), there is absolutely nothing to suggest that Xion's Keyblade is fake. QED. I find it ironic that you are actually fighting fire with sparks here.

Because destroying a young man's body automatically means that an old man's body will return. *this statement has been approved by the board of logic* [/sarcasm] Yeah, physically, it will be AX, but MX will be in control.

Hey, if a character gets enough positive feedback, then fanservice dictates that they have to come back in some capacity or another. And Vanitas was a total badass. However, for the sake of sanity, I don't think he should appear as anything more than a mention or a flashback (and maybe a bossfight, but as like a shadow or something). Bringing him back would mean you'd have Heartless, Nobodies AND Unversed running around. It would add diversity certainly..... wait, why is having three different enemies a bad thing?

Many of them are fangirls, so it's not what's got INTO their heads that's the problem. It's what's already there. *shudder*

I think we're all forgetting what Xion did with the Keyblade. She fought Heartless, and collected hearts, which joined Kingdom Hearts. A fake Keyblade would not be able to do this, seeing as only a real Keyblade will do. This is stated several times throughout Days, and a few times in KHII, a Keyblade is the only thing capable of releasing a captive heart, so a fake wouldn't be capable of it, seeing as a fake would merely hold the shape of the Keyblade, not its abilities. And, the Ultimania did not outright state it, it hinted at it (provided it's translated correctly).

I'm not arguing for the sake of argument. It was one throwaway line in the Ultimania that isn't referenced again. I can't find any record anywhere else that Xion's Keyblade is a fake, aside from the cutscene where Riku says it is, which is Riku's opinions on the matter. Last I checked, Riku wasn't gospel. Meanwhile, the re:Coded secret ending didn't hint at stuff; it outright said it.

'Every single bit of evidence'? One line in the Ultimania. That's the only evidence I've seen thus far.

One cutscene. One. And, he didn't believe that Xion was a part of Sora at the time (and as Sora is the only Keyblade Weilder he knows at this point, aside from Mickey, anyone else with a Keyblade must have a fake. It's basic logic, doesn't mean it's true).

One throwaway line? That all? Really? Seriously, that's not good enough.

That's weird, cos I can't find a single reference to that, like, anywhere. Quotes/Source plz.

I think we're forgetting the fact that after Xion's 'death', Roxas had access to both Sora's and Ventus's Keyblade. And due to the fact that Xion is an imperfect replica of Roxas, leeching his memories and so forth, we could probably assume that grants her access to either Sora's or Ventus's Keyblade (not exactly sure which, cos Roxas could have been using one or the other). Taking that into account, I think Riku either thought the Keyblade was fake, due to Xion's apparent lack of skill, or that she wasn't the true weilder of it, because she inherits it from Sora.