PlayBackKey

Exactly, that's why I said "We never see her face or any part of her body so we don't know if she has "the sygil" or not, she could have it just like everyone else". So that will be the one thing that will clarify everything once we know.

Hello! It's my first post here, and I wanted to share a little theory I being thinking about for a while. A lot of people have being theorizing about who's foreteller is the traitor, so I being looking around and although I might be wrong, it's very plausible, I will put links to different videos to support my theory. Well, I will start by saying who I think the traitor is: Forteller Ava. Nowhere says that the traitor must be evil nor have dark intentions, as we can see on X-BC the Master of Masters literally told her to "forget about the notion of unions" in order to save the light. He also told her to look for capable keyblade wielders, no matter their unions and "create and entirely separate organization", and that she's the only one who can do it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tyQepyoK37k (look from 1:04 to 1:30) He obviously told her in a subtle way to betray the unions for the greater good, although I think it was just to fulfill his plan. Given that she filled her role like the master told her, without giving it much thought. Then comes the events that we don't see here, the events of X [Chi]: Gula tells the player that the traitor is "the one unable to forgive this distastefulness, who thaught of fate with pessimism and lost true strenght, the one who will misread the truth and step into secrecy (Ava could've taken what the master said for the truth, and she clearly stepped into secrecy when creating the Dandelions) And for last, what makes me think about even more about it is this: Then gula says "and, with that one swing, the bell that tells the end of the battle will sound, and the battle will finally begin, at the destined time", and after that we see Ava swinging his keyblade at Luxu just as the clock reaches the 12:00 on the clock, making the bell sound, at the destined time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94M8NNNuEdc&t=1s&index=29&list=PLhcSrKyqhfh5gWWmRv4rISACTyrZbPPsS (look from 3:40 to 7:15) Ava by the masters orders created a separate organization, betrayed the five unions and they're beliefs by doing so, for the greater good yeah, but one thing doesn't change the other. It was the master's plan all along, as everyone can see, and used her and her kindness to make sure everything happens the way it was supposed to. We never see her face or any part of her body so we don't know if she has "the sygil" or not, she could have it just like everyone else. Luxu is the only one who makes clear to have it in his name, but that doesn't exactly means his the traitor, since the book says it's one of the foretellers and Luxu isn't one of them. Well that's my theory, what do you guys think? anything that you would add or change? I'd like to know your opinions. Please let me know if something is mispelled or has bad writing, i actually speak spanish so there could be anything wrong.

It was never officially said that she was born when sora used the keyblade of hearts so it probably was just taken as fact by everyone, we only know for sure that Roxas was created then. Although you still have a point that she knew about the hurting when repairing sora's memories. Maybe she reached terra's mind when being born somehow (if we make a timeline, by the time aqua finds terra in the realm of darkness, that it's after he spoke to namine, it would be almost on the same time period) but it wouldn't explain how she knew that help was coming. What it's certain is that Namine can make contact with anyone who has connection with Sora (she saved riku by entering his mind when he was being swallowed by the light in CoM for ex.), but until they explain how is it possible, we can just speculate. Well she said that she has been alone for a long time, weeks, maybe months if my theory of her being born in the beggining is correct and we also know that she started messing with Sora's mind when Marluxia obligated her. The answer is yes, after the events of CoM she stayed for little to no time in Castle Oblivion, then she along with DiZ moved Sora, Donald and Goofy to the basement of Twilight Town Mansion so they will be safe of being found. For me it's very unlikely, since at that time Ventus's heart was residing inside Roxas. So to conclude, yeah, Nomura has a lot of things to aswer about :tongue:

Well, if you think about it Kairi lost her heart (who rested inside Sora) at the beginning of KH1 and what was left of Kairi's body was nothing but an empty shell, maybe Namine was born then and not when sora stabbed himself (remember that no one knows how it's even possible that she exists, because kairi's body was not lost). The moment Namine contacts the LW is nearly at the end of KH1 so (and this is just a theory) that would explain how she was able to contact with terra's mind that rests inside the lingering will, because of his (and ven and aqua) connection with sora. Sorry if it's not perfect, I actually speak spanish :tongue: