For those of you guys who have a disdain for this theory let me give you an alternative take. Maybe instead of Demyx being the MoM, how about he is someone connected to him? Like with Sora, Roxas and Ventus.

Because not really gonna lie, I hope the MoM is not Demyx but rather a new character. Imagine the twist where the MoM finally unveils his hood and we completely see an unfamiliar face but Demyx somehow had a connection with this mysterious man. If Roxas shares the same face as Ventus what if Demyx shares the same face of somebody else that is connected with the MoM from a long time ago?

While that scenario is possible, I personally don’t expect them to go that route. I think Nomura’s top priority for the story is to expand the lore (and create weird mysteries and twists), so I think he’ll mostly shelve the Nobody twists moving forward; that lore’s pretty much contained to the CoM/KH2/Days era, anyway. And I’m willing to bet whatever his plans for Demyx are, they weren’t decided on prior to KH3’s development.

Even though Nobodies featured in KH3, I’m under the impression that it wasn't actually planned and it just happened that way during KH3’s development, similar to its usage of Replicas. (In other words, I’m convinced a lot of how KH3 turned out was due to Nomura having backed himself into a corner.)

If there are any more alternate versions / clone characters, I expect Nomura’s going to play into a multiverse angle instead. What form that takes exactly, I have no idea. I guess I think it's more likely that Demyx the Nobody is the nobody version of whoever Human Demyx is, who could be an AU version of the MoM or someone else. I'm not really into that theory, though. lol

I agree, I don’t want Demyx to be the MoM, either; Demyx being some crazy, ancient mastermind who was just pretending to be a lazy, college-age deadweight who’s surprisingly capable would steal his original character and appeal. lol I don't want the MoM to be anyone but a new character, although that greatly calls into question why his name is such a big deal. (I both suspect and fear that it's really not and it'll go down in the fandom as the biggest letdown of a mystery. lol?)

Edited March 27Mar 27 by DestinysUnion