I know this may have already been done, but I have to ask.

 

Okay so Xion is an incomplete clone of Sora? That right so far?

If the theories are right..... and people see who their memories first remember while looking at Xion (Or have strongest memories about)

 

Roxas sees Kairi, but HANG on.......He should have the memory of Ventus, so shouldn't he be seeing Ventus? Aka kinda himself? (even buried deep)

 

Xemnas sees Ventus.

 

Xigbar sees Ventus.

 

 

So here's my main Q -

 

Why Does Axel see Kairi? Did Lea have anything to do with her at Radiant Garden? Shouldn't he see Xion as Ventus? Since he met Ven as Lea?

ORRRR

Sora cause he met him at Castle Oblivion?

He never met Kairi until Kh2........Unless his meeting Namine has something to do why he sees Kairi?

 

Axel did say upon meeting Kairi "I feel like we're friends already"

 

Any theories? This one is bugging me.

Roxas saw Xion as herself, not Kairi. And Axel sees Namine (or at least says she looks very similar to Namine). I quote his secret report:

 

Honestly' date=' I never got why Roxas was so crazy about Xion. I know they both joined up around the same time, and they're both rookies, but how do you get so close to somebody who hides their face all the time? Well, I saw it today. All of a sudden, No. XIV up and takes off...her hood.

[b']Xion is a girl, and she looks just like Namin

Roxas and Axel don't see Kairi when they look at Xion. They see Xion. While Xion's face is base on Sora's memory of Kairi, that is still what Xion looks like.

 

I have heard that at first Axel didn't see Xion for herself. After he became friends with her did he see her as herself.

 

On another part of this, I have also heard that Xemnas saw Xion as Sora. I don't know if that is right or if he sees Ven. I think it is more likely if he saw Ven, but I'm not sure.

Because Axel and Roxas both consider Xion to be her own person, or as much as they consider anyone in the organisation a person, they see her for her self, which is the appearance of black hair and way too sulky for her own good face.

 

So Axel sees Xion as Xion, and mentions the resemblence to Namine because she looks like Kairi, who looks like Namine (at least they're supposed to, I don't see it) and he hasn't met Kairi yet. At first I'd imagine he'd see her as the hooded figure the player sees at the beginning, which despite meaning to have no gender, still looks decidedly female. Once they become friends he sees her for her. This is backed up by in some of the scenes as when they are from Roxas' point of view Xion has her hood down and when it changes to Axel's POV she has the hood up. It's not a mistake as I originally (and stupidly) thought.

actually, aparently, Xemnas sees her as something completely different, according to Xigbar's secret repotr.

From the novel, and the report, sometimes Axel sees namin

[As Sora's memories are the basis of her being, Xion initially resembles Kairi, who was Sora's strongest memory at the time of her birth, though her physical appearance eventually changes depending on who is viewing her and who they have connections with. Roxas, Axel, and Riku see her as Xion (and later as Sora), Xigbar sees her as Ventus, Xemnas sees her as Sora, while Sa

actually, aparently, Xemnas sees her as something completely different, according to Xigbar's secret repotr.

 

Just for the record, it is entirely possible that Xemnas actually sees her as Vanitas. I'd personally like to believe he sees Ventus, though evidently Xigbar's secret report says that he suspects that does not. I believe it would more come down to whether Xemnas has inherited more of MX or of Terra... if the former is the case, it is very possible that he sees Vanitas, whereas if the latter is the case (which I believe is, due Xemnas' connection with the Chambers of Repose and Waking and his "friend" (Aqua) and his "other friend" (Ventus)), the chances are higher that he does, in fact, see Ven.

 

Or, perhaps, neither is the case, and Xemnas sees Xion as Sora. But there are 2 things that turn me away from this idea: A) The way Xigbar says, "though I suspect that Xemnas sees entirely something else in her..." Sora seems like the most obvious option. Xigbar's proposition implies that Xemnas sees something perhaps unexpected, "entirely something else." B) Xemnas' relationships with Ventus and Vanitas are MUCH stronger than his relationship with Sora - he had a single encounter with Sora, whereas he has a long history with the former 2.

What everyone else said. Also, Xion is not a clone of Sora, she is a Replica of Roxas made of Sora's memories (as stated by Xemnas and Axel).