This is never easy to comprehend. (NEVER, I SAY!) So, just so I get my logic straight, I am briefing a node of help here...

 

So, in Wonderland, after collecting all 4 (or 3 if you're lax with that) pieces of evidence....I-I'm pretty sure that the one that you need to pick is the far one on the right, with the image of the Shadow. I don't know why, but it sounds right to me.

 

I remember in my first play through, I picked the second one and Donald pop out. ("Oh, crap!")...so there's a thing too.

 

Idk, I'm just getting things in order here...because let's be honest, the Queen Of Hearts boss fight that follows is a pain in the gludeous maximas if you end up locking up Donald, Goofy, or both. I mean, first off, you're not even fighting a boss, really, you're just breaking apart a Crank Tower while annoying Card Soldiers peg you endlessly. She doesn't even fight, she just sits on her damn throne and bitches at Sora and her soldiers ..which makes the fact that you can hit her, and when you do she falls over and shows her knickers, even more hilarious. lol. Anyways, it's just always wise to make sure, because I can never remember these things.

 

I'm still putting my munny on the fourth box. Anyone agree?

Edited December 1, 201212 yr by Firaga96

After consulting my guides book it appears as if the boxes are random. It's been a while since I played the first KH game but I think for me it's usually either the second or forth box.

it doesn't matter

I usually pick the middle....I dunno it seems legit. Either way you have to get Alice out of that cage by fighting someone

I assumed it was random.  However, if you do pick a box that has Donald and Goofy in it, you still can have access to them, you just need to break them out of the cage they are in by hitting it.

I assumed it was random.  However, if you do pick a box that has Donald and Goofy in it, you still can have access to them, you just need to break them out of the cage they are in by hitting it.

 

 

Really? You can do that?I just figured they'd stay put. lol

Really? You can do that?I just figured they'd stay put. lol

 

Yep, at least that's what I remember.  It's rather nice, though I get the heartless a lot of the time so it's not a problem

Yeah, it's completely random. I remeber i picked the same box in two differents games, but one of them had goofy and donald, and the other time, it had a shadow. But like it was said, you can free them by hitting their cage

In both of my KH1 play-throughs I've chosen different boxes and each time I got the Heartless, so I don't know...  I think the contents of the box change randomly each time.