MasterLorX

Having said that hearts shape vessels,then why didn't Roxas appearence change after he started growing this 'true heart' you're talking about? It seems to me he never started growing his 'true heart' (because he already has Ven's heart i believe)You said he has no Ven's memory, I think this is because Roxas is still Sora's nobody and this implies that he should have Sora's memories (but he doesn't because Sora was a Heartless for a short time).You also said that in DDD there are many dialogues hinting his return, from my point of view this is okay since Roxas=Ven and Ven is returning thus Roxas is returning (because he's Ven).At this point I think it is pointless to continue this debate, one day we'll know who's rightdo you agree?

There aren't any solid proof that can tell us if Ven's heart was dormant or if Ven's heart became Roxas heart. Until we discover this we can't be 100% sure about Roxas destiny in KH3.And in DDD they just say nobodies can grow hearts, without specifically say if Roxas did grow one, they only say he expressed emotion

You were right, Roxas first keyblade is Sora's and the second one is Ven's.However this doesn't completely destroy my theory, in fact I'm very suspicious about that "Roxas keyblade is Sora's", this implies Roxas doesn't have his own keyblade and this makes me think he can use a keyblade in the first place just because of Ven's heart being inside him. however we're missing the real point, in the end Roxas return as his own person is possible only if he really developed his own heart like Axel did. You say he developed his own and that Ven's one was inside him but dormant, instead I believe his heart is actually Ven's.

Ven's body location isn't important, in the KH universe a person is defined by his heart, and I don't think Ven's one was dormant when inside Roxasand he had no Ven's memories because he's still technically Sora's nobody.Now, the tricky part comes when we talk about Roxas keyblade, in fact I believe the keyblade he has since the beginning is Ven's one (in the form of kingdom key) and after Xion's death he absorbs her (but I'm not really sure about this) and gains the ability of dual wield.Saying Roxas can wield a keyblade because of his status as Sora's nobody is nonsense to me, since keyblade are connected to hearts and nobody don't initially have one.I'm not going to say I'm absolutely right and there's no possibility Roxas will return, but you guys have to say it is possible it might not happen and however as said before it would be awkward

sorry to crush your hopes guys, but I think it is highly probable that Roxas won't return and this is because he is Ventus (Ven's heart went inside Roxas after Sora sacrifice). Plus it would be super strange and awkward to make two identical characters return in KH3

You're right, I completely forgot about this, no keyblade of people's heart no Sora sacrifice and no massive feelings :')Well I think now everything makes sense, actually the explanation about the connection between FK, EoTW, DTD and RoD is just our theory and cannot be confirmed completely, but still is a very valid theory.ya know I feel like Nomura didn't intend to give these particular plot elements a real explanation, maybe he doesn't consider these elements important or maybe he just want us to use imagination

I agree, the FK must be connected to the RoD nice deduction you must be right! the endless abyss and the DTD are situated (and have always been) on the boundary between RoL and RoD, then because of previous events EotW came into existence and it happens to be situated next to the DTD (there must be a connection btw), this implies that in order to arrive at the endless abyss you must first go through end of the world Actually as far as I know the FK and the DTD becomes unlocked just by gathering the 7 PoH. In fact I have always thought the keyblade of people's heart to have been created by Riku-Ansem just to increase his strenght not to actually unlock anything. Just tell me if I'm wrong and let me know your theory about this

In KH1 the 7 PoH were gathered in order to get to the artificial Kingdom hearts of worlds' hearts situated in the RoD. Now, as far as i get gathering them unlocks the DTD and opening it you are finally able to get to KH, but then why do maleficent and Ansem SoD refer to the FK (final keyhole) as the mean to get to kingdom hearts and don't mention the DTD instead? Also where does the FK brings you exactly? It is implied that when Ansem went through it he arrived at 'end of the world' but, if this was correct, then how's possible Sora get there just by using the gummyship? And why does darkness seep from it? what is the FK connected to? It seems like the FK is actually a useless keyhole At last why does the DTD appear in 'end of the world' is it always been there or did Ansem SoD teleport us to the endless abyss? if the latter was the case then what's the point of arriving at EoTW? Thank you for your attention, hope I wrote in a clear English

Hi, I'm MasterLorX and I'm one of the biggest fan of this beautiful series. I love KH story and I like so much to unveil the mysteries and the secrets of the plot. This site is awesome and here I'm hoping to solve the doubts I have and in case to solve yours And of course I'm here to have fun with an awesome community:D