I don't think there's a thread about this exactly, or at least I couldn't find anyone. Anyway, something made me think about Namine earlier, and I realized that I really can't find a way for Namine to exist. Kairi had her body, so we know Namine wasn't actually Kari's body, plus Kairi never became a heartless. Apparently she was born from Sora's body, but I don't get how both her and Roxas could have the same body, and plus she rejoined with Kairi, not Sora. I really can't think of a possible way for her to exist, so what do you guys think?

I was thinking about the Namine thing too! It's been bugging me so much lately her existence...I mean, we always talk about the Roxas/Ventus thing, but it seems that Namine is just a completely new being...she came from Sora's body and Kairi's heart, so who knows what she really is? I really like Namine and hope she comes back eventually, it should work...

 

side note: I think I'm really going to like this website!

So that would kind of mess up Namixas, right? (I'm always looking for ways that wouldn't work... does that make me weird?)

 

Kind of. It's okay if you don't think about it too much though, but now that I think about it, Namine and Roxas do kind of act more like long lost siblings than a couple, don't they? Maybe that's just me

 

Nah, I'd say that's pretty normal 8D

But that would make Sora and Kairi the parents of them, and that would mean the siblings, Roxas and Namine, are going out as much as parents and I don't even know how to explain how weird this relationship is when thought out. So imagine going into your father or mother to complete them. It just doesn't work... so they are not siblings. *continues to shrudder at the thought of it*

Half-siblings, then. Or brother and sister with Sora and Kairi, like Namine is Kairi's sis, and Roxas is Sora's brother. But, completely unrelated to them, the two are brother and sister as well. Like in-laws. I think? I'm not making much sense even to myself anymore...

But that would make Sora and Kairi the parents of them, and that would mean the siblings, Roxas and Namine, are going out as much as parents and I don't even know how to explain how weird this relationship is when thought out. So imagine going into your father or mother to complete them. It just doesn't work... so they are not siblings. *continues to shrudder at the thought of it*

 

No one said it had to make sense. Think about the Xion relationships. It kind of reminds me of Dante's Inferno (puppet sex and whatnot). If they say Roxas can be in a relationship with a girl who happens to be a boy who happens to be a replica of him, then he can be in a relationship with his half sister. Roxas was born from just Sora. Namine was born from Sora and Kairi. Since Sora is their shared parent, that makes them half siblings.

 

Half-siblings, then. Or brother and sister with Sora and Kairi, like Namine is Kairi's sis, and Roxas is Sora's brother. But, completely unrelated to them, the two are brother and sister as well. Like in-laws. I think? I'm not making much sense even to myself anymore...

 

This entire situation is reminding me of a fanfic where Sora and Namine are twin siblings, who also happen to be half siblings, who also happens to be cousins. I didn't even know that was possible D:

Could somebody please respond, confirm, or deny my theory at the top of this page. I don't mean to be pestering, but I have looked over and over my main point and I don't see a flaw. And if I am wrong if one could please persuade me to think otherwise.

Could somebody please respond, confirm, or deny my theory at the top of this page. I don't mean to be pestering, but I have looked over and over my main point and I don't see a flaw. And if I am wrong if one could please persuade me to think otherwise.

 

Only thing I can suggest is to look over the thread with Grass's theory on it carefully, you'll probably find a counter-argument.

If by counter argument you mean a counter argument to what I was trying to say, that counter argument grass had was what I was pointing out a flaw in. If you mean a person on that thread who pointed out the counter argument I had, nobody pointed that out.

I don't deny Grass's theory but... Ansem's sounds better:

 

 

Namin

I don't deny Grass's theory but... Ansem's sounds better:

 

 

Namin