Okay,for short Heart-Nobody Theory explanations,Nobody and Heartless will born right after if someone loses a heart with strong will.However,for Ventus,in my opinion,after he lose a heart and became Coma while his heart was inside Sora,how come Ventus's Nobody and Heartless didn't born during that Time?Well,i have a theory on this one...

 

First of all,i think it would be confirmed that Ventus was clearly would be one of the Seven Guardians of Light.I know that Everyone can be one of it,but Ventus will clearly and mustly become one of the Guardians.The proof is that his condition was the same as the Princesses of Light.For example,Kairi has lost her heart but was deep inside Sora,but she was not turn into a Heartless during that time since Princesses of Light has pure heart of Light,which means they can't turn into a heartless unless in comatose state.Also,Kairi don't have a Nobody until Sora released her heart by stabbing the Keyblade into his heart and thus creating Namine.So my assumptions is that Ventus's heart was the heart of pure Light and he can't become Heartless,which means he was the same level as the Princesses but he would be the Seven Guardians of Light instead.And i think that Princess of Light and Guardians of Light can't become Heartless,but only have their Nobodies instead,much like Roxas,who is Sora's nobody but it was also Ventus's nobody too since Xemnas was the nobody of Terra and Xehanort at the same time as an example that one nobody can belong to two people.Also,during when Sora became a Heartless and Ventus's heart was inside Roxas,it is clear that the Heartless was belong to Sora after all,and not with Ventus....

 

So yeah,this is all the theory i've got.What are yours?

Edited August 13, 201312 yr by Hazimie

But Sora became a heartless, right? I think only princesses of heart have those hearts of pure light.

 

Ven's heart, however, was split in half, so there's no darkness inside his heart (because that darkness is Vanitas). So that explains why he didn't become a heartless.

That's made me just think of something! When Sora returns Ven's heart to him will a Nobody be created like how Naminé was created?

But Sora became a heartless, right? I think only princesses of heart have those hearts of pure light.

 

Ven's heart, however, was split in half, so there's no darkness inside his heart (because that darkness is Vanitas). So that explains why he didn't become a heartless.

This^ Ven's heart is made of pure light as stated above.And I don't think ventus's nobody is roxas although he got his looks from ven(since ven's heart got split and was in roxas,Ven can't turn into a heartless(since his darkness is vanitas)

That's made me just think of something! When Sora returns Ven's heart to him will a Nobody be created like how Naminé was created?

Maybe or something might happen to ven.

Okay,for short Heart-Nobody Theory explanations,Nobody and Heartless will born right after if someone loses a heart with strong will.However,for Ventus,in my opinion,after he lose a heart and became Coma while his heart was inside Sora,how come Ventus's Nobody and Heartless didn't born during that Time?Well,i have a theory on this one...

 

First of all,i think it would be confirmed that Ventus was clearly would be one of the Seven Guardians of Light.I know that Everyone can be one of it,but Ventus will clearly and mustly become one of the Guardians.The proof is that his condition was the same as the Princesses of Light.For example,Kairi has lost her heart but was deep inside Sora,but she was not turn into a Heartless during that time since Princesses of Light has pure heart of Light,which means they can't turn into a heartless unless in comatose state.Also,Kairi don't have a Nobody until Sora released her heart by stabbing the Keyblade into his heart and thus creating Namine.So my assumptions is that Ventus's heart was the heart of pure Light and he can't become Heartless,which means he was the same level as the Princesses but he would be the Seven Guardians of Light instead.And i think that Princess of Light and Guardians of Light can't become Heartless,but only have their Nobodies instead,much like Roxas,who is Sora's nobody but it was also Ventus's nobody too since Xemnas was the nobody of Terra and Xehanort at the same time as an example that one nobody can belong to two people.Also,during when Sora became a Heartless and Ventus's heart was inside Roxas,it is clear that the Heartless was belong to Sora after all,and not with Ventus....

 

So yeah,this is all .the theory i've got.What are yours?

 

 1-Ven didn't lose his heart to darkness- it sought refuge in Sora as his physical body slept in CO therefore no heartless or nobody to be formed 

 

2- Kairi didn't really 'lose" her heart per se when it was hidden in Sora- it sought refuge there just like Ven's heart sought refuge in Sora . Neither formed nobodies when this happened 

 

3- When Kairi finally did make a nobody it was bc her heart was released from SORA's physical body - although still no heartless formed of course .Namine in herself is an anomoly- the very definition of a true nobody since she technically is not suppose to even exist yet she breaks all the rules of a nobody.( she doesn't even have a physical body)

 

4- So you are saying that the Guardians of light have to be pure light? Well not according to in game canon candidates. MX and Mickey were listing possible lights and not all of the other possibilties listed were pure light. Most weren't actually. Nomura said anyone could possibly be a light even Donald and Goofy and they aren't pure light 

 

5-  For the record, Xemnas and Roxas were both said to be 'special nobodies' by Nomura bc their circumstances were different from most nobodies. However even then their circumstances were different . Roxas had Sora's body and Ven's heart . Ven's heart wasn't 'fused' with Sora's when Roxas was born - they existed separately in Soras body and only one of them was released when Sora stabbed himself.( Sora's)  Since Ven's heart wasn't released and stayed in Sora's body  Roxas took on Ven's appearance but doesn't have Ven's or Sora's memories.( that's why he was a 'zombie' at first). Xemnas was formed from Terra's physical body but MX and Terra's merged/fused hearts and used both guys memories. ( eraqus in there somewhere)