I know this has been asked before but whatever here we go again.

 

I'm playing through Birth By Sleep again and than I remembered in KH2 when Goofy told you that Mickey banished pete.

 

• Retcon?
• Error?
• Do I need to read all reports and journals in KH2 again 0_0?
• Naminé messed up?
• Goofy is being Goofy -_-
• Goofi is being Goofy because lazy writing -__-

Edit: How do Donald and Goofy not know Yen Sid lives in the tower did he never told them that?

Can somebody clear the hole Yen Sid tower thing for me in full details please.

It's Goofy. He probably got some detail wrong somewhere.

Minnie banned Pete in order of Mickey .

Cant we just chalk it up to the fact that all 3 of them just spent a year in a giant egg having their memories unhinged and jumbled, so much that maybe their memories are still a little messed up.  I mean, they arrive at the Mysterious Tower what, like and hour after waking up from a sleep for a whole year? I feel like this is probably the best explanation.  They dont remember correctly because they spent the last year getting their memories all jacked up

Inconsistencies like that are part of why I think ever since BBS, Nomura has just been making up plot points as he goes along with no clear direction or regard for what was established in the first two games.

Cant we just chalk it up to the fact that all 3 of them just spent a year in a giant egg having their memories unhinged and jumbled, so much that maybe their memories are still a little messed up.  I mean, they arrive at the Mysterious Tower what, like and hour after waking up from a sleep for a whole year? I feel like this is probably the best explanation.  They dont remember correctly because they spent the last year getting their memories all jacked up

Yet they clearly remembered every other event, character and location they previously visited. Not buying that.

Yet they clearly remembered every other event, character and location they previously visited. Not buying that.

 

Please.  Sora didnt even remember turning into a Heartless, an event in which he stabbed himself in the chest and turned into a monster, until the end of the game

Please.  Sora didnt even remember turning into a Heartless, an event in which he stabbed himself in the chest and turned into a monster, until the end of the game

There's a difference between having a memory jogged, and completely forgetting something took place. The restoration scenes even showed him being turned into a heartless after stabbing himself, so he clearly still knew about it.

So which is it?  Was his memory jogged or did he just completely forget?  I think he legitimately completely forgot, just like Donald and Goofy forgot about the Tower.  Even when Yen Sid was talking about Nobodies and the Heartless, at no point was Sora like "Hey, I turned into a Heartless, does that mean I have a nobody too?"  It wasnt until he talked to Riku that he remembered, and even then it took him a second.  I just dont think its so far fetched to say that since we are debating over why Donald and Goofy dont remember the tower right after they spent a whole year having their memories swapped around and screwed up that the two events might be connected.  They both deal with memory, and they just had a huge procedure done to their memory.  I dont feel like thats a coincidence, and Nomura could have and should have said so.  It would have made more sense than "the floors changed"

There's a difference between having a memory jogged, and completely forgetting something took place. The restoration scenes even showed him being turned into a heartless after stabbing himself, so he clearly still knew about it.

sorry I forgot to quote you on my last post