Note: This is a special chat topic! This means that posts can be shorter and more casual here. Posts here are linked with and may appear on our Discord server.

I saw a post on Twitter of some fan art of Sora singing to Kairi and Kairi laughing because she thinks he is a terrible singer and one of the replies was that Sora should stick to dancing and cooking. What are your thoughts on this?

He should stick to swinging that keyblade

Then who would be left to sing, to dance and to cook?

I mean, HJO really wasn't the best

Compared to Irino Miyu, huh?

Well, when you consider the fact that most western fans haven't been exposed to the Japanese dub...

A few years after KH2, he sang a full Japanese cover of Under the Sea which he also sang in KH2 as Sora

Here it is

I can post other Irino Miyu songs in

If a Japanese VA sings in-game, their English counterpart has to sing too. And there’s nobody on the English cast who I’m particularly excited to hear sing.

What about the Japanese cast?

Irrelevant. KH doesn't do dual audio.

I meant to the second thing said

I don’t know the Japanese cast, and even if I did it doesn’t change my point

Well there is Miyu Irino (Sora)

Who became a well-known Japanese singer after 2009

All I know about the Japanese dub is that it's pretty bad outside of a few select characters (yes, I consider Sora one of them)

He sings mostly J-pop songs and anime themes

But I thought the Japanese version was the original version of the game?

Being the original doesn't inherently make it better

Anyway, what do you think of Irino's music outside of KH?

Like those examples I shared in

Decent. I don't have a significant opinion on it.

Maybe it’s just me and my complete lack of an understanding of their language and culture, but from what I’ve heard of it the Japanese VA is nowhere near as good at conveying tone and emotion.

But yeah

I believe that KH2 led to Irino starting his music career four years after the release in Japan as that is when he started making music

And now, back to my original question, if that is the case, who do you think should be left to do those three things?

The Disney characters

So this means something like only Donald and Goofy should perform the Atlantica numbers and Sora should just watch?

Everybody except them

Then how would Sora be able to express himself with music?

If he can't sing or dance

Playing a song he likes on a speaker?

Like given what you have said, how do you think he would be able to show how he is with music if he can't sing or dance?

Melody of Memory has missed so many chances at this