This is a theory I literally just thought of. Lets all move back to KH1, when Sora released the hearts he had from within him. He had Kairi's and Ventus' heart, and the results were Roxas and Namine. Namine was created under odd conditions, since Kairi's heart was incorruptible, because it was a heart of pure light. But Ventus' heart was a heart of pure light as well, so wouldn't something similar to Namine have been created? Just something to think about.

I think of Roxas as Sora and Ventus' Nobody, just two bits of people (heart, body, whatever) in one form, Roxas. The real thing is, who is Sora's true Nobody since Roxas is like what I stated above..... Geez, I'm terrible with theories.

Well, it's most likely been stated that Aqua's spell she placed on Kairi back in BBS may have something to do with how Namine got created. Plus, might I add the fact that Namine was made due to Karir's PoH powers as well as from Sora's body? As for Ventus,well, it's unlikely that he has a Nobody. Even though the fact that his heart is full of light and also the fact that his heart is in Sora's body, he would have to pruduce a Heartless in order to create a Nobody as well. And last time I checked,his heart left his body after his fight with Vanitas and his body was locked in C.O.

 

I think of Roxas as Sora and Ventus' Nobody, just two bits of people (heart, body, whatever) in one form, Roxas. The real thing is, who is Sora's true Nobody since Roxas is like what I stated above..... Geez, I'm terrible with theories.

Well, Sora's true Nobody is just Roxas since a nobody is created with the body of their origional selves. Remeber, Roxas was made when Sora stabbed his heart to save Kairi. So as soon as his body faded into bits of light, his body was transformed into Roxas.

Pretty much what they ^ said, Roxas is Sora's body + Ven's heart then that means Ven's heart wasn't released when Sora lost his heart and Ven's body is in CO removing all possiblities of Ven having a Nobody. But then again there's Nomura and his plot twists...

Pretty much what they ^ said, Roxas is Sora's body + Ven's heart then that means Ven's heart wasn't released when Sora lost his heart and Ven's body is in CO removing all possiblities of Ven having a Nobody. But then again there's Nomura and his plot twists...

 

Actually, Ven's heart did leave Sora's body. It just went into Roxas soon after Sora lost his heart.

Actually, Ven's heart did leave Sora's body. It just went into Roxas soon after Sora lost his heart.

 

Or you can basically say that the Ven's heart never left, just stayed with the body and soul as it was forming. No need to complicate things.

when ven got into roxas heart then roxas went back into soras body so ven was again in his heart!!!!!

I don't know, I've thought about it before but I don't know for sure. Then why wouldn't princess Aurora produce a heart in Sleeping Beauty? So I think the qualifications for producing a nobody are losing your heart completely to the darkness. Remember, how Sora actually turned into a heartless, darkness claimed his heart. Kairi's heart had no darkness but part of Sora was put into Namine produced the same way Roxas was.

Ven can't have a Nobody, since a body is needed to make a Nobody. It's been shown that Ven's body is sleeping in Castle Oblivion.

A Nobody comes about when a person's heart takes a physical form as a heartless. The body then fades away, the body will either become a Nobody or take shelter in Kingdom Hearts.

For some reason, when a person releases their heart. Eg. Ven or Kairi. A nobody is not created, because the body does not fade. (It's possible the mind is keeping it alive or something.)

Ven can't have a Nobody, since a body is needed to make a Nobody. It's been shown that Ven's body is sleeping in Castle Oblivion.

A Nobody comes about when a person's heart takes a physical form as a heartless. The body then fades away, the body will either become a Nobody or take shelter in Kingdom Hearts.

For some reason, when a person releases their heart. Eg. Ven or Kairi. A nobody is not created, because the body does not fade. (It's possible the mind is keeping it alive or something.)

 

On the contrary, a body isn't actually needed to make a nobody. Take for example Kairi who's body never actually disappeared from the realm of light. Also were did you get the idea that the body takes shelter in kingdom hearts, because I always thought it was that the body remains on the world it disappeared from. I think it was because they had pure hearts that the true body remained in the rol.

 

 

For the original question: If Ven's heart left Sora along with kairi's heart, then Ventus would have a nobody much like Kairi having Namine

I am surprised keystrike is the only person who fully understood my question. There is a reason I put Nobody in quotations, meaning I know that it is impossible for Ventus to have a regular Nobody, but it IS possible that something like Namine could have been created since his heart was in the exact same predicament as Kairi's.

On the contrary, a body isn't actually needed to make a nobody. Take for example Kairi who's body never actually disappeared from the realm of light. Also were did you get the idea that the body takes shelter in kingdom hearts, because I always thought it was that the body remains on the world it disappeared from. I think it was because they had pure hearts that the true body remained in the rol.

 

 

For the original question: If Ven's heart left Sora along with kairi's heart, then Ventus would have a nobody much like Kairi having Namine

 

Namine is a weird exception and we don't know exactly how she was born, but a lot of people believe she was partly made from Sora's body.

As for the body disappearing to Kingdom Hearts. Slight speculation. I believe I read it in a few different places, and so I believed it to be almost fact. The reason for it being that a heartless is defeated, the heart goes to KH when a Nobody is defeated as well as the heartless, the person is brought back. So, it would make sense for bodies to be kept in KH as well as hearts.

Namine is a weird exception and we don't know exactly how she was born, but a lot of people believe she was partly made from Sora's body.

 

Well, that's how Ansem states it.