Thinking about buying one or the other for the Gamecube. Don't know why I didn't buy these before

 

Anyways, which one do you think is better? Or should I just save up and get both?

 

 

Had no idea people liked Wind Waker so much lol

Edited July 11, 201213 yr by HeiTheFlamingRamen

Windwaker. TP is better,in my opinion on the wii

Wind Waker

Wind Waker

Windwaker was really fun for me and so was TP but I say windwaker, it really plunged me back into the zelda series when I bought my gamecube

 

Wait on second thought I say get both, besides gamecube games aren't very expensive these days right?

Edited July 11, 201213 yr by WakelessDream

BOTH

 

Wind Waker.

Windwaker was really fun for me and so was TP but I say windwaker, it really plunged me back into the zelda series when I bought my gamecube

 

Wait on second thought I say get both, besides gamecube games aren't very expensive these days right?

 

Yeah, I think I'll get both. Twilight Princess is the more darker, realistic Zelda. While Wind Waker is the more cartoony, fun Zelda.

 

And I think they are pretty cheap, though both Zelda games are more expensive than a lot of GC games. About $30 for each.

In retrospect, Twilight Princess is one of my least favourite Zelda games, though I did enjoy it the first time I played it. Wind Waker, on the other hand, is one of my favourites. After Skyward Sword and A Link to the Past that is.

Wow, I'm surprised at the amount of people saying Wind Waker, but in fairness I've only ever played about 5 minutes of it because I don't own it myself. But, honestly, TP is probably my favourite LoZ game besides OoT3D. Skyward Sword would be third.

But yeah, although TP probably is better on the Wii (which is what I have it on), if it's just a choice between TP/WW I'd go for TP.

If you can, just get both.

Edited July 11, 201213 yr by Xalaru

Wind Waker is one of the, if not THE enjoyable Zeldas out there. Twilight Princess is by no means terrible, but it pales in comparison to Wind Waker.

Wind Waker. People might get on its case because of the graphics, but it has to be one of the most fun Zelda titles. The game makes you want to explore the world, rather than just book it across Hyrule field, and that's something special.

Twilight Princess is the only LoZ game I've played, and I loved it, and if this is considered to be the least best one, then I got into this series too late.

Twilight Princess is the only LoZ game I've played, and I loved it, and if this is considered to be the least best one, then I got into this series too late.

 

Yeah, Twilight Princess is still a great game, yet one of the worst in the series. Tells you something about the series, doesn't it?

If you were to get TP on the wii, I would say TP, but since you're using a gamecube, go for Wind Waker. The graphics are really beautiful.

If you were to get TP on the wii, I would say TP, but since you're using a gamecube, go for Wind Waker. The graphics are really beautiful.

 

Why exactly would you say that...? I mean, there's barely a difference between the Gamecube and Wii versions in the first place...

Why exactly would you say that...? I mean, there's barely a difference between the Gamecube and Wii versions in the first place...

 

I mean that the controls are much more better on the wii than on the gamecube, that's just my opinion. You might get a better experience on the wii than on the gamecube.

I mean that the controls are much more better on the wii than on the gamecube, that's just my opinion. You might get a better experience on the wii than on the gamecube.

 

Well, I've only played the Gamecube version extensively, but I found that while aiming was vastly improved, slashing your sword tended to be finicky.

And that really doesn't say much in comparison to Wind Waker...

Well, I've only played the Gamecube version extensively, but I found that while aiming was vastly improved, slashing your sword tended to be finicky.

And that really doesn't say much in comparison to Wind Waker...

 

I wasn't comparing ww to tp, how about I rephrase what I posted. If you have a gamecube but not a wii, I suggest that you get ww over tp. If you have a wii it's better to get tp on the wii than on the gamecube.

I wasn't comparing ww to tp, how about I rephrase what I posted. If you have a gamecube but not a wii, I suggest that you get ww over tp. If you have a wii it's better to get tp on the wii than on the gamecube.

 

But this is about choosing between Wind Waker and TP. You can play Wind Waker on the Wii, so if you're recommending getting TP for the Wii, it implies you're suggesting getting it over Wind Waker.

But this is about choosing between Wind Waker and TP. You can play Wind Waker on the Wii, so if you're recommending getting TP for the Wii, it implies you're suggesting getting it over Wind Waker.

 

Yes, I prefer tp over ww, but other people may have disagree with me. If you wanna continue this, just pm me instead, before this topic gets locked.

Yes, I prefer tp over ww, but other people may have disagree with me. If you wanna continue this, just pm me instead, before this topic gets locked.

 

All I want is clarification on your opinions, I'm not here to change them.

All I want is clarification on your opinions, I'm not here to change them.

 

On the gamecube I prefer WW, on the wii I prefer TP.

On the gamecube I prefer WW, on the wii I prefer TP.

 

Well yeah

But what specifically?

Well yeah

But what specifically?

 

Do you mean why specifically I would prefer WW over TP on gamecube, and vice versa on the wii.

Do you mean why specifically I would prefer WW over TP on gamecube, and vice versa on the wii.

 

Anything, really

Anything, really

 

Well, on the wii version of TP, I thought that the controls felt cooler and smoother than the gamecube's TP controls. WW is a great game, but in my opinion can't beat TP's experience on the wii. The game in the Legend of Zelda that was a let-down for me was Skyward Sword. What about you?