Roxas or Terra?

 

This isn't a who will or won't, just a "if you had to choose who would it be"

 

Terra by far.

Roxas. Terra is a boring character that is just a big plot device. Roxas is a really good character

Can I pick the invisible "both" option? 

It would depend, if it was Roxas with the false personality DiZ gave him, then I would prefer to see Terra back. But if Roxas had his personality from 358/2 Days, and remembered who Axel was, and had his real personality back, then I would prefer to see Roxas. It all would depend on would they be portray, which would make me decide who I would like to return.

Well that's kinda hard... But I would pick Roxas. 

I haven't played BbS, so I don't really have a connection with Terra that much as a character. Even though he's one of the main in the game, he was the foolest of all the three, blindly following Xehanort and calling the worst decisions of all time in KH history

I also picked Roxas because he's one of my favorite characters. His story is one of the sadest in the game, and though Days had a horrible gameplay (I just hate collecting those Org. XIII badges!) it's story was one, if not, the best stories in KH. So I've been waiting for his "happy ending" for longer than Terra.

(It's kinda hard to pick one and it seems we don't about the other at all! I just want to keep clear I hope Terra is reunited with Ven and Aqua)

Roxas all day everyday

I want to see Terra back, I miss mah babeh. I've seen enough of Roxas.

Roxas.

I would like to see Roxas return

I think I'd rather see Roxas too.

Terra's voice actor sucked, also terra wasn't all that smart. In the beginning of kh2 and 358/2 as a whole, a begun to really appreciate him realize how great of a character roxas is.

They both got it pretty bad and I'd hate to only see one of them return, but if I had to pick, Roxas.  After everything he's been through, I think he deserves something going his way for once in his existence, have it actually last, and most importantly, be completely founded on something genuine.  Part of his tragedy is that he never really had a chance to be his own person and lead his own life.  His whole existence revolved around things beyond his control that he doesn't understand, being manipulated and used and locked out of the loop about everything.  His trusted best friend withheld the answers he desperately sought, and his other best friend ran off to fix a problem that there was no way he could've solved because he was part of that problem.  He had to merge with Sora because he never would've woken up without him, and come DDD, Roxas has essentially brainwashed himself into thinking anything he felt is worthless because he has no identity outside of Sora.

 

Roxas lost everything he considered important, and there was nothing he could've done to prevent it.  Throw the guy a bone, sheesh.

Roxas by far.

They both got it pretty bad and I'd hate to only see one of them return, but if I had to pick, Roxas.  After everything he's been through, I think he deserves something going his way for once in his existence, have it actually last, and most importantly, be completely founded on something genuine.  Part of his tragedy is that he never really had a chance to be his own person and lead his own life.  His whole existence revolved around things beyond his control that he doesn't understand, being manipulated and used and locked out of the loop about everything.  His trusted best friend withheld the answers he desperately sought, and his other best friend ran off to fix a problem that there was no way he could've solved because he was part of that problem.  He had to merge with Sora because he never would've woken up without him, and come DDD, Roxas has essentially brainwashed himself into thinking anything he felt is worthless because he has no identity outside of Sora.

 

Roxas lost everything he considered important, and there was nothing he could've done to prevent it.  Throw the guy a bone, sheesh.

Wow, You make it sound really depressing

They both got it pretty bad and I'd hate to only see one of them return, but if I had to pick, Roxas. After everything he's been through, I think he deserves something going his way for once in his existence, have it actually last, and most importantly, be completely founded on something genuine. Part of his tragedy is that he never really had a chance to be his own person and lead his own life. His whole existence revolved around things beyond his control that he doesn't understand, being manipulated and used and locked out of the loop about everything. His trusted best friend withheld the answers he desperately sought, and his other best friend ran off to fix a problem that there was no way he could've solved because he was part of that problem. He had to merge with Sora because he never would've woken up without him, and come DDD, Roxas has essentially brainwashed himself into thinking anything he felt is worthless because he has no identity outside of Sora.Roxas lost everything he considered important, and there was nothing he could've done to prevent it. Throw the guy a bone, sheesh.

I love all of the thought you put into your responses! And Roxas does have it pretty bad. Who knows maybe in this game he will finally get the happy ending he deserves

I hope to See Roxas return and Terra because they need to be Revived and fight against the 13 Darknesses.

This is honestly not an decision to make, but when it really comes down to it, I would choose Roxas, absolutely.  Like Dracozombie mentioned, his entire existence was wasted and he was abused emotionally to a very substantial extent.  And even in his end, he was only able to partially justify his brief existence, in that he realized the true identity of Sora as the "chosen keyblade wielder", and the true identity of himself, as a part of him.  However, he still left without really saying goodbye to Axel, the way I personally believe they both deserved, given what they went through during their time in the Organization.  Essentially, his miserable existence was something he truly had no power to overcome, and that, simply put, just isn't right.  As for Terra, I really did enjoy his character, and would love to see him return as well, however, I carry Roxas as more of a worthy candidate in this instance in that Terra gave in to darkness, albeit it was out of frustration, he still submitted himself to the darkness in order to defeat his enemy, which we know by now is not the way to go about things.  Submitting to darkness as a result of frustration may seem like a reasonable action, but in the grand scheme of things, it only made the situation worse. In short, Terra, who was actually in control of his destiny (to an extent), kind of messed things up for himself.  However, Roxas truly had the odds stacked against him, I feel, and overall I believe he deserves to return and justify his existence, or at the very least, say goodbye to Axel/Lea.

Edited July 18, 201312 yr by Xetorph

Both but if I had to choose roxas

Terra.

Roxas, we know so much about him, we saw him getting hurt.. being happy 

 

Terra, what do we know about him ?!

Roxas, he's the first character that I felt had a super compelling plot in kh2 and even now the phrase

" looks like my vacation is over"

Causes me to burst in tears

Roxas.

Terra. He needs some good old fashion revenge.

Roxas, he's the first character that I felt had a super compelling plot in kh2 and even now the phrase" looks like my vacation is over" Causes me to burst in tears

Oh you cried at that too? It's so sad

Oh you cried at that too? It's so sad

Is it strange that the only sad scenes in Kingdom Hearts that i actually felt sad involved Roxas, Xion and Axel? Just saying. 

 

Btw Roxas over Terra. Roxas needs some happiness considering all the trash life threw at him. Like Dracozombie said his life basically has involved him being used by Org XIII and Diz and Riku, being given a life only to have it forcefully ripped away, losing his memories (bad though some of them were) and losing his two best friends....did i miss anything?