So if Xion's form changes based on who is looking at her (Saix sees her in her puppet form, Xigbar sees her as Ven, Roxas sees her as Kairi with black hair, and Axel often sees her with just a hood on), how does Xion see herself? We never really have many scenes from her point of view: she's almost always in a position where we are seeing her as someone else does. There's the assumption that she shares her sense of identity with Roxas, but really, there's no real reason to support that: as said before, her appearance is almost arbitrary. 

I would assume Sora.

 Axel also initially saw her as Namine bc he hadn't met Kairi yet but eventually he saw her as Roxas did so I think she also sees herself like Roxas did - the black haired Kairi which is what those close to her saw.

Edited February 9, 201411 yr by Flaming Lea

I assumed the black-haired Kairi.  Since Roxas and Axel also see her that way, I defaulted to thinking she sees herself that way as well.  The confrontation between her, Axel, and Xigbar in Wonderland where she runs off, seems to support she didn't see herself as Sora or whoever until then.  If the fact she's just a puppet without her own identity was such a shocker to her, it stands to reason she never looked into a mirror and saw a boy.

Jennifer Lopez

She sees herself as Jennifer Lopez

I think black haired Kairi because she was a Roxas clone so I'd guess they saw her the same way

Xion...Man I'm so confusing...Who am I...I really don't have an identity do I?...*looks down all sad*

she sees herself as Rihanna...

Mos likely black haired KH1 kairi, but I do hope when she's free and her own being her appearance changes...  The reverse Kairi cut looks like a badly done DIY emo job.  

Even if they just change her fringe, I would be happier.

She saw herself as Lightning

In a mirror.

I'd say how we see her, since she does brush her hair behind her ear, indicating that she at least thinks she has some where we see it, and she definitely seemed to notice when she started to look like Sora, suggesting that it wasn't her normal look.

As Xemnas explains, when Sora's memories started leaking into Xion, "it" began to transfer into "her": the being they all saw. Naminé also confirms this, when she says that Xion's the "Kairi that Sora remembers", and that she can see her face: the black haired Kairi.

 

Someday, I really ought to write up just what I imagine Xion is. There seems to be a lot of confusion there. She's definitely not Roxas (as she was meant to be a clone of Sora), but she actually already existed as a blank slate before his memories started transferring over.

 

Honestly, I don't see Xion as Sora or Roxas. She could have been anyone/anything, and was always changing. Originally, she was an empty husk, but developed an identity of her own: everything else was really just smoke and mirrors. And since we know she grew her own heart (and will come back as her own person eventually), that furthers the fact that her existence was separate from Sora and Roxas'. In fact, if Sora's memories had never been scattered in the first place, she and Sora could have co-existed with no problems.

 

Also, I imagine that when she becomes her own person, she'll still look the same as she does now to everyone else, as that's how they perceive her. "I see myself the way you remember me, and you see yourself the way I remember you," and all that. Joshua further adds to this in explaining, "It's when other people look at us and see something, that we each truly start to exist." (Or something like that.)

Can anyone please tell me who I am?! Everyone is saying all of this and no one really knows my existence...I feel like I have no identity at all...Like I'm wasn't ment to be here in the first place...I was born into this world from being created by Sora's memorise...I was suppose to be a copy of him. I'm like...I am an experiment but...I don't want that...I want my own life! I want to be a real person! I want to be me! I want to EXIST!!! I want...I want...I want to have a heart beating inside me...I don't want to have a fake life. I want a real one...Because I'm...I'm me...I'm Xion...Thats who I am...Thats who I always been!

Can anyone please tell me who I am?! Everyone is saying all of this and no one really knows my existence...I feel like I have no identity at all...Like I'm wasn't ment to be here in the first place...I was born into this world from being created by Sora's memorise...I was suppose to be a copy of him. I'm like...I am an experiment but...I don't want that...I want my own life! I want to be a real person! I want to be me! I want to EXIST!!! I want...I want...I want to have a heart beating inside me...I don't want to have a fake life. I want a real one...Because I'm...I'm me...I'm Xion...Thats who I am...Thats who I always been!

 

It's fine, Xion. I like you just the way you are. Who else will I have Ice Cream with, without you?

It's fine, Xion. I like you just the way you are. Who else will I have Ice Cream with, without you?

Thanks...thats means alot

Thanks...thats means alot

You are Xion, and Xion you will forever be.

You are Xion, and Xion you will forever be.

 Axel also initially saw her as Namine bc he hadn't met Kairi yet but eventually he saw her as Roxas did so I think she also sees herself like Roxas did - the black haired Kairi which is what those close to her saw.

 

He says that because the girls have similar body structure/hairstyles...Axel's POV in the actual scene goes straight from "hooded puppet" to "black haired girl" without a transitory phase.

 

Even disregarding stuff like physical appearance and "I'm a replica D:", Xion views herself as undoubtedly female; she consistently uses the very girly first-person pronoun あたし atashi in the Japanese version and is, as far as I know, the only original character to do so.

 

Assuming she comes back in KH3, her final appearance will probably be "black-haired Kairi" since that's how everyone close to her perceives her (note how Sora, who has never seen Xion before, sees her as "black-hair" before anything else happens).

Edited February 9, 201411 yr by Ultima Spark

She sees herself as a puppet . A puppet is a puppet .(Yeah I just said that , Sora96 )

She sees herself as a puppet . A puppet is a puppet .(Yeah I just said that , Sora96 )

"I'm going to ignore the main themes of the entire series"

Man people don't even know who I really am...Thats really sad...Though who am I anyway? I really feel like I have no identity at all...Everyone sees me different...Well I guess I will remain a mystery to everyone

He says that because the girls have similar body structure/hairstyles...Axel's POV in the actual scene goes straight from "hooded puppet" to "black haired girl" without a transitory phase.

 

Even disregarding stuff like physical appearance and "I'm a replica D:", Xion views herself as undoubtedly female; she consistently uses the very girly first-person pronoun あたし atashi in the Japanese version and is, as far as I know, the only original character to do so.

 

Assuming she comes back in KH3, her final appearance will probably be "black-haired Kairi" since that's how everyone close to her perceives her (note how Sora, who has never seen Xion before, sees her as "black-hair" before anything else happens).

  Agreed, I'm just directly referring to his report where he says she looks like Namine which makes sense since he hadn't met kairi yet .I realize I didn't phrase it right but that's what I was referring too. I just meant he didn't always see her as hooded but eventually saw her as looking like Namine but as the black haired girl that Roxas also saw 

 

 

Edit : Here is the report i was talking about but i'm sure you know this :

 

Day 74: Xion's Face

Honestly, I never got why Roxas was so crazy about Xion. I know they both joined up around the same time, and they're both rookies, but how do you get so close to somebody who hides their face all the time? Well, I saw it today. All of a sudden, No. XIV up and takes off... her hood. Xion is a girl, and she looks just like Naminé.

Edited February 9, 201411 yr by Flaming Lea

She thinks of herself as a girl

 

So her own persona but with the appearance of kairi